Chad's Blog

But on this one will I look: On him who is poor and of a contrite spirit, and who trembles at my Word. Isaiah 66:2

Feb 14, 2016

Gender Roles: Who Submits to Whom?

I saw a commercial for Buffy the Vampire Slayer the other day in which a feminist observed how Buffy fulfilled her warrior calling with the same kind method and nuance as any other male.  That may be true for heroine of Joss Whedon’s cult hit, but is it true of women in general?  Is there any differentiation in the roles of men and women, particular in a marriage?
          Marriage vows used to look much different in days gone by.  Certain things were asked of the man, while different things were asked of the woman.  Yet today, marriage vows tend to be identical for each gender. 
          The Apostle Paul wrote in Ephesians 5:22-23, “Wives, submit to your own husbands as to the Lord, for the husband is the head of the wife as Christ is the head of the church.” 
          Paul’s teaching about the roles of husbands and wives was quite revolutionary at the time, as the prevalent culture didn’t see men and women as equal.  Yet at the same time, it’s revolutionary in our culture that tends to see men and women as the same without any distinct roles or callings.  So even though there’s some overlapping in being male and female, they each are still distinguishable ways of being human with distinguishable gifts and callings in marriage. 
          Notice Paul doesn’t tell wives to love their husbands, but to respect him.  He doesn’t tell husbands to respect their wives, but to love them.  He tells husband and wives both to submit in verse 21, but then tells the wives to submit a second time in verse 22.   The wife is not told to work for the perfection of her husband so she can present him before the throne, spotless and without blemish. 
          So does this mean that the wives don’t have to love their husband, but just respect them?  Or that a wife is not supposed to work for her husband’s maturity and sanctification?  Of course it can’t mean that because those things are taught in other places.  So the only reason Paul would lay out these different instructions is because men and women are good and bad at different things.  Recognizing this, Paul emphasized different things for each, because each possesses different gifts and roles. 
          Contrary to the Buffy enthusiast, there’s plenty of evidence that men and women will go about the same job in different ways.  Tim Keller quoted a study that concluded, “Men tend to see themselves maturing as they separate and become independent and make an impact.  Women see themselves maturing as they attach to others and become interdependent.”  In other words, men have the gift of independence, while women have the gift of interdependence, which seems to fit well with what scripture says. 
          Now with the obvious differences between husbands and wives, a lot of the more conservative believers will assemble a long list of specific and very stereotypical roles.  They may say that the husband should work and the wife should stay home with the children.  I know many couples that make that work them, and that’s wonderful.  But where does the Bible specifically say that?  Or that the woman cooks, and the man is in charge of the checkbook?  That works for some marriages, and that’s good for them.  But where does the Bible specifically say that?
          Before the industrial age, husbands and wives both stayed home and worked to produce goods together, whether it was farming or raising livestock or making clothes.  They both worked to produce goods and they both raised the children.  It wasn’t until the industrial age that for the first time someone had to get up and leave the home to go to place of work.  The husband usually went to off to work while the wife stayed home and raised the children.  Yet the Bible doesn’t nail itself down into those kinds of specifics for the roles of husbands and wives.
          Proverbs 31 talks about a woman of worth.  She into real estate and investments, she does sewing and child rearing, and there’s no reason to think that her husband was doing all those things with her.  So when we talk about the Bible’s teaching regarding the traditional family, we cannot hone the Bible to the traditions of one particular place in history.  In light of this, there seems to be great amount of freedom in how a wife contributes to her home and to her family.
          When Paul says in vs. 22, “Wives, submit to your own husbands as to the Lord, for the husband is the head of the wife,” he is referring us back to Genesis with the important word, “head.” 
          This word has a primary meaning of “source.”  It could be used to refer to the headwaters of a river, being the river’s source.  The Greed word here for “head” is just like our word, “authority.”  If I write a piece of poetry, I am the author.  Therefore since I am the source of the poetry, I have the authority to inform you of what the poetry is about.  So when Paul is referring back to Genesis where Eve is taken out of Adam, Adam is in a sense the source and headwaters of Eve.  So when Paul says what he says, it is because of the way things were set up at creation.
          In the first chapters of Genesis, there are two things crucial for understanding marriage.  First, the man and woman were created as namer and helper.  Secondly, husband and wife’s original nature of being a namer and a helper was cursed and corrupted because of sin. 
          God tells Adam to name the animals.  In the Bible, naming something was to take charge of shaping its character and purpose.  A parent would name a child because the name reflected the kind of child they would hopefully grow up to be.  God would change a person’s name when he would change their nature. 
          When God creates Adam to name the animals, he obviously wants him to have an impact on shaping the character of the world.  Eve, on the other hand, was created to be a helper.  The problem is that we tend to think of a helper as being weak without the ability to really contribute much.  We tend to think of how a child might help his dad build a doghouse.  He can’t really help, but he can get the hammer for his dad and maybe hand him a nail or two. 
          Biblically the word “help” is an extremely sophisticated term that is almost always used of God, as God is our help in time of trouble (Psalm 46:1).  A helper, therefore, is someone with power and resources you don’t have.   Eve, being created as Adam’s helper, implies weaknesses and deficiencies in Adam that Eve doesn’t have, and that Eve possesses power and resources that Adam doesn’t have.
          For example, I can help my son with his math because I know more about math than he does, but there’s two ways that I can help him.  I can bring my help in such a way as to enable and empower him, or I can bring my help in such a way as to replace him where I just do the math for him.  And yet if I do it for him, I’m not really helping him.  Therefore, a wife has the gift of using her strength and power in such a way as to enable and empower her husband.   
          This doesn’t mean that women don’t name animals or that men aren’t supposed to help their wives.  But each has a gift that makes them strong in certain areas.  When we talk about women having a gift of interdependence while men have a gift of independence, we don’t mean that women are to never be independent or that men are never to be interdependent.  We are talking about things in which each gender excels, therefore when a husband and wife come together, they complete each other.  They each have strengths that fill in the gaps of the other’s weaknesses. 
          So the first basic truth from Genesis is that men and women are created differently.  The second basic truth is that they and their strengths have been corrupted by sin.
          God says to Eve in Genesis 3:16, “I will intensify your labor pains; you will bear children in anguish.  Your desire will be for your husband, yet he will rule over you.”
          God says to Adam in verses 17-19, “The ground is cursed because of you.  You will eat from it by means of painful labor all the days of your life.  It will produce thorns and thistles for you, and you will eat the plants of the field.  You will eat bread by the sweat of your brow until you return to the ground.” 
          Notice that when God curses humanity, he curses each gender differently.  He curses Adam’s work so that Adam’s desire to subdue and bring order to his world by way of his work will become an idol.  In other words, his work will become too important to him.  It will be a continual source of frustration because it will never really fulfill him. 
          God then curses Eve’s relationships.  She will desire her husband desperately, but he will want to dominate her.  Her gift of interdependence is corrupted into dependence where she wants to be taken care of.  Adam’s gift of independence is corrupted into tyranny. 
          So the traditionalist that rails on about the husband’s need to rule over his wife and get his wife under control is forgetting the curse.  They are forgetting the fact that men will tend to oppress women and that women will tend to make it easy for them.  Their fallen natures and corrupted gifts can feed off each other in destructive cycles. 
          The fact is that men and women in marriage are supposed to learn to submit to one another, and the husband is supposed to have a loving authority.  The wife is to use her helpership to continually pull her husband back from tyranny and autonomy, while the husband is use his strength to pull his wife back from dependence and helplessness. 
          So what then is a wife’s submission to her husband?  I must be tie-breaking authority.  The traditionalists believe the wife is the submitter while the husband makes all the decisions for the family.  Yet marriage, being the ultimate friendship between two people where iron sharpens iron, there will be contention at times as each one grabs the other and pulls them away from the corrupt use of their gifts.   
          So normally in marriage, the husband and wife will sit together and try to figure out what the best decision is.  But what happens when they just can’t agree?  What happens when a decision has to be made?  What if you’re trying to decide what school the kids should attend, or what house to buy, or what neighborhood to live in?  What if it’s a decision that will impact the whole family, but an agreement can’t be reached?  The Bible’s answer is to let the husband break the tie.

          When the husband initiates loving leadership in his home, and the wife ultimately and graciously defers to her husband, the Bible says that they are getting in touch with something deep inside that dates back to creation.  The two of them are becoming more masculine and more feminine, and together a more complete image of God.  As a result, the marriage is strengthened, the next generation is discipled, and God is glorified.  

No comments: